You probably think the oldest winery in the U.S. is out in California, right?
Surprise, it’s actually hiding in New York, just a short drive from the city.
This place has been around a long time, and you can tell the moment you step inside.
We’re talking massive stone cellars, old-school wine barrels, and bottles with more stories than your grandma at Thanksgiving.
They have tastings and tours, so whether you’re big on wine or just after a fun day trip with some history mixed in, this spot has something for you.
So where is it, what makes it special, and how has it lasted this long?
Keep reading because this one has a wild backstory.
Where Is It?
Brotherhood Winery is located in the quiet village of Washingtonville, right in the Hudson Valley.
It’s about 75 minutes from New York City by car, just under an hour from White Plains, and around 90 minutes from Albany.
Tucked in Orange County, it’s a super easy day trip from pretty much anywhere in the region.
About
Brotherhood Winery isn’t just any winery, as it holds the title of the oldest operating winery in America (yep, you read that right).
It has been making wine since before the Civil War and has become a go-to spot for wine lovers and weekend explorers looking for a sip of something historic.
The winery is also known for its extensive lineup of wines, from dry reds and crisp whites to sweet dessert wines and seasonal blends.
Fan favorites include their Riesling, Cabernet Sauvignon, and the spiced holiday wine that practically tastes like Christmas in a glass.
If you want to explore, you can join a guided tour through their massive underground cellars and then hit the tasting room for a flight of their most popular pours.
You’ll also find a charming gift shop packed with fun local goodies and wine-themed accessories you’ll be tempted to bring home.
Hungry? Drop by the on-site 1839 Restaurant & Bar for rustic dishes that complement the whole experience.
And if your trip falls in the summer or fall, keep an eye out for live music nights, outdoor tastings, and special events that turn the winery into a full-on party spot.
With everything it offers, it’s a chill, welcoming place, and whether you’re new to wine or have strong opinions about tannins, you’ll feel right at home here.
History
So how did Brotherhood Winery earn its title as the oldest winery in America?
Let’s rewind to 1839.
That’s when a man named John Jaques began growing native grapevines in his backyard and making wine for sacramental use for his local Presbyterian church.
Word spread quickly about the quality of his early batches, and the little operation gained a strong reputation under its original name, Blooming Grove Winery.
Then in 1858, the winery passed to his sons, who kept it thriving until it changed hands in 1886 and officially became “Brotherhood Wine Company.”
The business grew after that, and the wines spread far beyond the local area.
And eventually, Prohibition arrived.
Brotherhood actually survived those dry years by producing sacramental wine for churches, which was one of the legal exceptions at the time.
Because of that loophole, the business was able to keep operating while many others shut down.
When the ban ended, Brotherhood was still standing and ready to start up again.
In the decades that followed, the winery changed hands a few times and continued to expand, both in production and in opening its doors to visitors.
And today, Brotherhood Winery blends old-school tradition with modern winemaking, producing thousands of cases every year.
It’s also part of the Shawangunk Wine Trail and holds a proud place in New York’s booming wine scene, all while staying true to its roots.
Know Before You Go
Best Time to Visit
Brotherhood Winery is open most of the year for tours, tastings, and events.
If you’d like to catch outdoor tastings, live music, or the full festive vibe, late spring through early fall is your best bet.
They often host their Grape Stomp event toward the end of summer, and the crisp air plus changing leaves add a special touch to the visit.
Hours
The winery keeps fairly regular hours during most of the year.
From April to December, it’s open Tuesday to Thursday from 11 AM to 5 PM, Friday and Saturday from 11 AM to 6 PM, and Sunday from 11 AM to 5 PM.
It’s closed on Mondays and has shorter hours in the winter, so be sure to check their website before you go.
Nearby Things to Do
Got more time? There’s plenty to explore nearby.
Just 20 minutes away is Legoland New York Resort, a colorful theme park filled with rides, giant Lego builds, and fun photo ops that make for a playful detour.
A short 15-minute drive to Schunemunk Mountain State Park gets you scenic trails, rolling hills, and fresh air if you want a little nature between tastings.
You’re also super close to the rest of the Shawangunk Wine Trail, so if you’re into winery-hopping, Brotherhood makes the perfect starting point.
Whether you’re in it for the history, the wine, or just a chill day trip out of the city, Brotherhood Winery is one of those spots that totally lives up to the hype.
Related Posts
