Long Island isn’t just about beaches, bagels, and battling traffic on the LIE—it’s also home to some of the dreamiest small towns you’ll ever find.
We’re talking about waterfront villages where sailboats drift by, and cozy downtowns filled with mom-and-pop shops.
Then there are hidden spots that feel like a mini vacation just an hour from the city.
Some of these towns have historic theaters and old-school ice cream parlors.
Others have vineyards, ferry rides, or even cliffs overlooking the water (yes, actual cliffs on Long Island).
Whether you’re in the mood for a peaceful harbor stroll, a killer lobster roll, or a little small-town magic, these spots deliver—so get ready to explore.
1. Northport
Northport is a picture-perfect harbor town on Long Island’s North Shore, about an hour from NYC, with a waterfront straight out of a postcard.
It’s famous for its charming Main Street, packed with mom-and-pop shops, cozy cafés, and the John W. Engeman Theater, which opened in 2007.
The town’s biggest claim to fame?
It has stunning harbor views, a dreamy waterfront park with a massive gazebo, and the legendary Cow Harbor Day festival.
Every year, locals celebrate their seafaring history with a parade and other events like the Crazy Boat Race, and the Great Cow Harbor 10K Run.
If you love old-school ice cream parlors, stop by Lics, a local favorite serving up sundaes and milkshakes for over 25 years—because no trip to Northport is complete without a scoop (or three).
2. Greenport
Greenport, on Long Island’s North Fork, has that salty, sea-breeze kind of charm that makes you want to ditch your car and explore on foot.
This former whaling village is now a lively mix of waterfront seafood shacks, indie boutiques, and historic sites.
One standout is the East End Seaport Museum, where you can learn about the area’s maritime past (or just admire the cool old lighthouse models).
If you’re into wine, you’re in luck—Greenport is surrounded by some of Long Island’s best vineyards.
You can hop between tasting rooms like Kontokosta Winery, which has unreal views of the Long Island Sound.
Oh, and don’t leave without riding the Greenport Carousel!
This hand-carved beauty from the 1920s is still in Mitchell Park—because no matter how old you are, spinning around on a vintage horse is always a good time.
However, be aware that the carousel is currently closed for mechanical repairs.
3. Sayville
Sayville has that classic small-town feel that will keep you coming back for more.
It’s the gateway to Fire Island, so you’ll see plenty of beachgoers hopping on ferries.
But the town itself is worth a visit for its adorable downtown, packed with antique shops, bakeries, and one of the best brunch spots around—Sayville Bean Coffee House.
If you’re into history then check out the Sayville Historical Society.
You can also take a walk through The Common Ground, a peaceful little park with a ‘labyrinth’.
And if you want the full Sayville experience, grab a drink at The Sayville Inn, a local institution since the 1800s, where the seafood is fresh and the beer is cold – just how it should be.
4. Babylon
Babylon is next up on the list and it’s one of the South Shore’s best-kept secrets.
The village is packed with waterfront restaurants and local favorites like Glen’s Dinette, a retro-style breakfast spot that’s been flipping pancakes for years.
If you’re up for a stroll, Argyle Park is the place to be, with its scenic lake, charming footbridges, and plenty of ducks to watch.
And for the ultimate sunset spot, head to Tanner Park.
Here you can watch the sky turn pink over the Great South Bay while live bands play on summer nights—pure Long Island magic.
5. Bellport
Bellport is the kind of artsy, waterfront village that feels like a secret getaway, even though it’s just over an hour from NYC.
The downtown is small but packed with character—think art galleries, farm-to-table dining at The Bellport, and the historic Gateway Playhouse theater.
Locals have access to Ho Hum Beach, a quiet Fire Island spot only reachable by ferry.
But even if you’re just visiting, Mother’s Beach is a great place to soak up the bay views—just keep in mind that swimming isn’t allowed.
And if you’re into history, swing by the Bellport-Brookhaven Historical Society for a peek into the village’s past.
It has everything from colonial-era artifacts to stories about the town’s old shipbuilding days.
6. Huntington
Huntington is where Long Island’s small-town charm meets big-city energy, with a downtown that’s always buzzing.
You’ll find some of the best restaurants on the island here.
You have upscale options like Prime where you can indulge in steak and sushi, or more casual eateries like Little Vincent’s where you can grab ‘cold cheese pizza’.
Music lovers should check out The Paramount, a legendary venue where everyone from major rock bands to stand-up comedians take the stage in an intimate setting.
And if you need a break from the action, head to Heckscher Park.
It’s perfect for a picnic, a peaceful walk, or just hanging out by the duck pond—because every great Long Island town seems to have one.
7. Westhampton Beach
Westhampton Beach is next up on the list, where soft sand and rolling waves make it a prime spot for sunbathing, surfing, or just pretending you live here full-time.
Downtown has a mix of chic boutiques, cute cafés, and the historic Westhampton Beach Performing Arts Center.
There, you can catch everything from indie films to big-name concerts in a beautifully restored theater.
If you’re craving sweet treats, head to The Beach Bakery & Grand Café, which is a local favorite.
8. Cold Spring Harbor
Cold Spring Harbor feels like stepping into a storybook, with its quaint streets, waterfront views, and just the right amount of history.
Head over to the Whaling Museum which has cool old harpoons and ship models that tell the tale of the town’s seafaring past.
Main Street is small but packed with charm.
Make sure to head over to Sweetie Pies on Main, a bakery-meets-coffee shop where the pastries are almost too pretty to eat (almost).
And if you’re up for a little adventure, Cold Spring Harbor State Park has a killer hiking trail with hilltop views that make you forget you’re anywhere near the city.
9. Sea Cliff
Sea Cliff is like Long Island’s own little Victorian dream, with colorful old houses, winding streets, and some of the best views of the Long Island Sound.
This tiny North Shore village is packed with artists, musicians, and just enough charm to make you want to move there immediately.
The town’s cliffs (yes, real cliffs) lead down to Sea Cliff Beach, a peaceful spot where locals sip coffee on the boardwalk and watch the sailboats drift by.
For the full experience, hunt for vintage treasures at one of the town’s funky antique shops or visit the Sea Cliff Mini Mart—an annual arts and crafts exposition.
Just keep in mind that the event takes place on the first Sunday of October, so be sure to check their website or Facebook page before planning your visit.
10. Oyster Bay
Oyster Bay is where history, nature, and seriously good seafood all come together in one perfect North Shore town.
It’s best known as the home of Sagamore Hill, Teddy Roosevelt’s summer estate.
You can tour his mansion, explore the nature trails, and maybe even spot a few wild turkeys roaming the grounds.
Down by the waterfront, The Oyster Bay Brewing Company is the go-to spot for a cold beer.
If you’re in the mood for a quick bite, the Bonanza Stand serves up boardwalk treats like Italian ices and fast food.
And if you happen to be in town for the Oyster Festival, get ready for shucking competitions, pirate shows, and more oysters than you could possibly eat in one weekend.
11. Port Jefferson
Port Jefferson is the kind of waterfront town where you can spend the whole day wandering and never get bored.
The ferry to Connecticut comes and goes, but the real action is on Main Street, packed with cool boutiques, homemade fudge shops, and restaurants with prime harbor views.
Make sure to grab a table at The Steam Room for some legendary clam chowder.
History fans can check out the Long Island Explorium or the Mather House Museum.
For anyone with a sweet tooth, a stop at Ralph’s Famous Italian Ices is a must—because nothing beats a cold, sugary treat after a day by the water.
Just a heads up, they close over the winter and normally reopen in March.
If you time it right, Port Jeff’s winter Charles Dickens Festival turns the whole village into a Victorian Christmas scene.
It’s complete with carolers, costumed characters, and enough holiday cheer to make even a Grinch smile.
12. Mattituck
Mattituck is North Fork wine country at its best, where vineyard views, farm stands, and small-town charm all come together.
The big draw here is Love Lane, a tiny but perfect street lined with local gems like Love Lane Kitchen (get the pancakes).
Then, there’s The Village Cheese Shop, where you can build the ultimate picnic spread.
Speaking of picnics, you’ll want to hit up one of the many wineries nearby.
Macari Vineyards and Lenz Winery are both local favorites, with rolling vineyard views and plenty of pours to sample.
And if you’re visiting in summer, don’t leave without stopping at Wickham’s Fruit Farm (nearby in Cutchogue) for fresh berries, homemade pies, and the kind of cider donuts that disappear way too fast.
13. Malverne
Malverne is one of those blink-and-you-might-miss-it villages, but if you do, you’re seriously missing out.
This cozy South Shore town has a real old-school feel, with tree-lined streets, and a tiny but charming downtown.
Locals swear by Connolly Station, an Irish pub where the burgers are great, the beer is cold, and there’s always a game on TV.
And if you’re visiting in winter, the town’s annual Holiday Lighting Ceremony turns Malverne into a Hallmark movie set.
It’s complete with twinkling lights, hot cocoa, and enough small-town cheer to warm even the chilliest night.
14. Sag Harbor
Sag Harbor is the next dreamy small town that you need to check out.
Once a major whaling port, the town still holds onto its seafaring roots.
You can check out old harpoons and ship logs at the Sag Harbor Whaling & Historical Museum (closes over winter and normally reopens in Spring).
The streets are lined with indie bookstores, art galleries, and legendary spots like The American Hotel, where you can sip a cocktail and pretend you’re in a 1920s novel.
And if you’re looking for a perfect sunset, Long Beach (Foster Memorial Beach) is the spot.
With calm waters, pink skies, and just the right amount of sea breeze to end the day.
Related Posts
