Florida is the capital of key lime pie and people are flying in just to get a taste.
We’re talking buttery graham cracker crusts, tangy lime filling, sky-high meringue, and chocolate-dipped frozen treats that’ll make you forget regular dessert even exists.
From roadside diners to tiki bars, this state is packed with spots serving up some of the best key lime pie on the planet.
If you’re ready to chase the ultimate slice (or seven), keep reading because these pies are so good, you might end up booking a flight before you even finish the post.
1. Palm Beach Grill, Palm Beach
Palm Beach Grill is located in the heart of Palm Beach, just a quick stroll from the beach and fancy Worth Avenue shops.
It’s known for its key lime pie with freshly whipped cream and a graham cracker–pecan crust, served ice-cold on a chilled plate.
The restaurant has a swanky but cozy vibe, with leather booths, dim lighting, and a buzzing open kitchen where you can watch your steak (or pie) being prepped.
This pie is so famous and has been listed as a must-eat in magazines like Southern Living.
2. Old Key Lime House, Lantana
If Palm Beach Grill is the classy dinner date, Old Key Lime House in Lantana is the fun beach party you never want to leave.
This place has been around since 1889, making it Florida’s oldest waterfront restaurant, and it’s got major tiki bar energy with bright colors, live music, and unbeatable views of the Intracoastal.
Their key lime pie is tangy, topped with whipped cream, and is a signature item on the menu.
You can eat your slice right on the dock with the salty breeze in your hair and pelicans flying by, which honestly makes it taste even better.
3. Fireman Derek’s Bake Shop, Miami
If you’re more into bold flavors and sweet tooth overload, Fireman Derek’s Bake Shop in Miami is your kind of pie stop.
This dessert wonderland has two locations—one in Wynwood and one in Coconut Grove—and both are packed with giant slices of pie and cookies the size of your face.
Their key lime pie is a creamy, punchy dream with a thick graham cracker crust and a filling that’s just the right mix of tart and sweet.
It was created by a real Miami firefighter-turned-baker, which makes it feel like the most delicious local legend you’ve ever tasted.
4. Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen, Key Largo
Now if you’re heading down to the Florida Keys, you have to make a pie pit stop at Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen in Key Largo.
This fun roadside diner has been serving up comfort food since 1976, and their key lime pie is so famous it’s basically its own tourist attraction.
It’s smooth, tangy, and topped with whipped cream, and yes, you can order it frozen to take home.
The hanging lights are covered in license plates, the vibe is super laid-back, and the pie is pure Florida in every single bite.
5. Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory, Tavernier
Just a bit farther down the road in Tavernier, you’ll find the Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory and the name is just as fun as the place itself.
This quirky little shop is famous for its creamy, award-winning key lime pie, recognized in local and regional contests (we’re talking serious pie cred here).
You can grab a classic slice, but the real move is their frozen key lime pie on a stick, dipped in chocolate—totally addictive and perfect for eating in the Florida heat.
There’s a peaceful garden out back with lush plants and outdoor seating, so you can chill with your pie like you’re living your best tropical life.
6. Sweet Savannah’s of the Florida Keys, Marathon
Keep cruising through the Keys and you’ll hit Marathon, where Sweet Savannah’s of the Florida Keys is waiting with even more pie magic.
This cozy little dessert shop looks like a pastel-colored dream and doubles as a bakery and ice cream parlor, which means dessert options galore.
Their key lime pie is super smooth, perfectly tart, and served chilled, making it a perfect treat on its own.
Locals swear by it, and if you’re lucky, you’ll catch one of their rotating seasonal treats, which change throughout the week.
7. Blue Heaven, Key West
When you roll into Key West, Blue Heaven is one of the highlights on your key lime pie road trip.
This funky outdoor restaurant is set in a backyard with roosters wandering around, live music playing, and trees growing right through the deck.
Their key lime pie is piled with a mountain of golden-brown meringue that looks like it’s reaching for the sky, and yes, it’s just as fluffy and delicious as it sounds.
It’s been featured on multiple food and travel videos, and honestly, no key lime pie road trip is complete without a slice from this iconic spot.
8. Kermit’s Key Lime Pie Shop, Key West
Kermit’s Key Lime Pie Shop is the other Key West legend you have to hit before leaving the island.
With its bright green trim and eye-catching exterior, this place is impossible to miss and even harder to forget.
They’ve got a few locations around town, but the original on Elizabeth Street is where you’ll find the famous pie that’s cool, creamy, and packed with authentic Key lime flavor.
You can get it by the slice or try one of their frozen chocolate-dipped bars…trust me, once you’ve had one, you’ll start dreaming in lime.
Related Posts
