Some restaurants are known for their food, others for their views, but this one is famous for both.
Perched high above the water, this hillside spot offers a front-row seat to sunsets painted in brilliant shades of orange, pink, and purple.
People start showing up well before sunset, proving this is much more than just another place to grab a meal.
If you’re looking for a place with scenery you’ll never forget, keep reading because this hillside restaurant might have the best sunset view in all of New York.
Where Is It?
The Montauket is located at 88 Firestone Road in Montauk, at the eastern tip of Long Island in Suffolk County, New York.
If you’re driving, it’s about 2 hours and 50 minutes from New York City, 1 hour and 15 minutes from Riverhead, and 55 minutes from Southampton, depending on traffic.
About
The Montauket has been one of Montauk’s favorite gathering spots since the late 1920s, and it’s best known for its sweeping views of Fort Pond Bay.
Locals call it “The Hill,” where you can watch the sun set over Gardiner’s Island.
The outdoor deck is the star of the show, with rows of picnic tables facing the bay so you can settle in with a drink and enjoy the changing colors in the sky.
There’s also live music on select days, creating an even more fun and lively atmosphere.
Inside, you’ll find a casual dining room and bar with a laid-back coastal style that matches Montauk’s easygoing personality.
The focus here isn’t fancy fine dining but casual meals, cold drinks, and plenty of time to soak up the view.
It’s the kind of place that brings together Montauk locals, weekend visitors from New York City, beachgoers, and boaters making their way to the eastern end of Long Island.
So if you can, arrive a little early to snag a table and see why the view truly lives up to its reputation.
Menu Items
The Montauket serves a casual American menu with plenty of fresh seafood and classic comfort food.
You’ll find favorites like lobster rolls, Cajun fish tacos, fried calamari, homemade crab cakes, steamed mussels, and both New England and Manhattan clam chowder.
If you’re in the mood for a sandwich, choose from options like soft-shell crab, fried flounder, chicken cutlet, grilled chicken, or an Angus burger.
For something even more filling, there are hearty entrées like sea scallops, fish and chips, seafood platters, grilled steak, and BBQ ribs.
Behind the bar, you can order local and imported beers, frozen cocktails, and signature mixed drinks like the Montauket Sunset, Crazy Mary, or Pirate Juice.
There are also wines, hard ciders, hard seltzers, and non-alcoholic beverages, so there’s something for everyone.
Whether you’re stopping in for a light lunch, a seafood dinner, or just drinks with a few appetizers to share, it’s easy to see why people keep coming back.
Know Before You Go
Hours and Best Time to Visit
The Montauket’s bar and kitchen are open seven days a week, with food served from 2 p.m. Tuesday through Thursday and from noon Friday through Monday.
If you’re hoping to catch the famous sunset, plan to arrive 60 to 90 minutes early, especially on summer weekends when the outdoor tables fill up quickly.
Bring a light jacket or sweater if you’re staying into the evening because the breeze off Fort Pond Bay can feel surprisingly cool, even during summer.
Getting There & Parking
The Montauket is easy to reach by car and offers free on-site parking, although spaces can fill during peak dinner hours.
If you don’t want to drive, take the Long Island Rail Road’s Montauk Branch to Montauk Station, then take a quick 3-minute taxi or rideshare to the restaurant.
Prices
Prices are moderate, with entrées generally ranging from $26.95 to $39.95, sandwiches from $19.95 to $23.95, and drinks offered at a variety of price points.
Nearby Attractions
Before or after your meal, spend some time exploring nearby attractions that showcase the best of Montauk.
You can visit Montauk Point Lighthouse, just a 15-minute drive away, where you can climb to the top for panoramic views of the Atlantic Ocean and Block Island Sound.
Just 12 minutes away is Montauk Point State Park, a great place to hike scenic trails, spot adorable seals, explore the rocky coastline, or enjoy a day outdoors.
If you’re in the mood for a relaxing afternoon, head to Ditch Plains Beach to swim, catch some waves, take a walk along the shore, or hike the nearby trails.
Related Posts
